This is trivia for people who love a good chill — and maybe a little regret. Truly Terrifying Trivia is packed with random true crime facts and generally creepy knowledge that’s equal parts fascinating and unsettling.

The twist? You’ll choose your questions from misleading categories that sound harmless… until they absolutely aren’t. For example, “Suicide Squad” isn’t a movie reference — it’s about Dr. Kevorkian. It keeps everyone guessing, laughing nervously, and saying, “Why do I know this now?”

With multiple ways to play and plenty of eerie facts to go around, this trivia game is perfect for spooky season, game nights, or gifting to that friend who loves true crime podcasts just a little too much.

Details:

200 trivia cards focused on creepy and terrifying facts
Misleading (and darkly clever) question categories
Instructions included for 3 different ways to play
Designed for 2–8+ players
Box size: 3.5" square x 3" deep
Fun, unsettling, and impossible to forget

All things ship for $3, all of the time.

gift

Filters

Truly Terrifying Trivia